Perhaps you were wondering, "That's all fine and dandy, but why not just start with the computer and save a step altogether?" Probably because John Williams is king, works with Steven Spielberg, and is in his 90's. He doesn't need to. He can hire out all the people to take care of the things that he doesn't want to do, things that don't excite or interest him, things that obviously need to get done but that he just doesn't have the headspace to finish himself.
It seems balanced to me how this works: John Williams composes the way he composes because it has obviously worked for him and the films he's worked on. Three Academy Awards to boot. And yet, he outsources the less sexy parts of that process to others that he trusts to get the job done correctly. In other words, there's a balance between the tasks that are extremely fulfilling and meaningful for him (the composing) and the tasks that need to be completed but don't excite him probably one bit (inputting notes on a computer scoring program, extracting parts, etc).
In the age of artificial intelligence, there's a temptation to wonder if computers can do everything for us. For example, I know of many people who already rely upon AI to produce everything in their business, from writing content for their blogs (I use AI to proofread and make suggestions for better flow, just to be clear) all the way to creating entire companies with tightly wrapped, branded products. I have heard of photographers completely letting go of grabbing their camera and letting AI create an image for them. Ditto for YouTubers looking to get a new piece of content for their channels. I’m constantly on the defence for taking time to create teaching materials or blogs because of the time and energy it costs me. I just can't bring myself to export the process for someone, or something, to handle for me. I can't just have AI write a blog for me. You'd know it in a second that the blog was written by AI. It would annoy you. Or, I assume it would.
Besides, the deeper issue is what happens when we let something who has pretty much no skin in our game as artists create for us. When we allow a robot who basically doesn’t care beyond excuting a prompt correctly to create for us, are we not losing something in the process? I dare say that we lose some of our agency and sovereignty... hell, I think we are losing boatloads of our passion as creatives. Do we really want that, just in this dogged, damned effort to save time, make money, and feed this stupid content machine? Just to make ourselves feel better and important that we have this digital assistant that does our dirty work for us for free? Sounds a little... boujee.
In coming back to the example of John Williams, a man who works with a pencil, a piano, and composes using just his own wits and personal musical history, can we not take a little something from his example in our own lives?
The answer lies in what we wish to do with our time.
Are there tasks that only we should do? Surely. Are there tasks that we probably shouldn't do and leave to a computer? Surely. The trick is figuring out which tasks belong where, and I believe that's a conversation we ought to have with ourselves, often.
Perhaps a couple of obvious examples will do here.
Would I want an AI to meditate for me every morning? Rhetorical question.
Would I want a robot to do Yoga for me every morning? Ditto.
Do I want AI to decide what Eurorack patch I want to create? What guitar chord to play? How to compose a melody? No, no, and no. I like doing all of these tasks. They make my life richer, more fulfilling, and I love feeling the agency in the work that I choose.
But certainly, I can find tasks for computers that seem super unsexy to me. For example, a chunk of my day is spent taking a close look at which emails deserve a response. Thankfully, many email programs automatically filter emails according to importance. I take liberal advantage of that. The only exception is when I get an unsolicited email about SEO placement offers. I love laughing out loud at their emails right before I spam the living shit out of them.
Another task? Scheduling guitar lessons. I remember the dark days of my teaching practice when I scheduled all lessons by hand, in a paper scheduling book. I would have at least four back-and-forth email exchanges between prospective students, and half the time, they wouldn't show up for their first lesson. It felt awful to sit outside my office, waiting for a student who would just never come. So, when online booking came around, I instantly saw the potential. When a student booked a first lesson, I gave this person the choice of time slot, immediately. I also gave them information like directions to my office, where to park, and what the first lesson is like. I also required payment on the first lesson, which cut down the amount of no-call-no-shows. Systemizing the booking of lessons instantly saved me three hours of work each week, hours that I could spend doing something more fun, like writing songs.
Let's do one more: I spend a large part of my Thursdays aggressively soliciting for more press and promotion opportunities for the albums on my record label. The hours I spent researching blogs! The hours I spent writing emails, trying to get them to listen, following up! Yuck! I remember clearly the moment when I found a couple of services that filtered promotion opportunities for me. Now, my music got submitted to hundreds of places automatically, and if a blogger liked the music they wrote about it. I could submit the music I wanted to promote to potentially thousands of blogs in 5% of the time. I felt a huge weight lift away from my shoulders. This freed up a good chunk of time to do things I enjoy doing a lot more, like writing blogs like this one.
The point is, I want to keep doing the tasks that give me a sense of fulfillment, tasks that define me as a human being, just as Matthew Crawford states in The World Beyond Your Head. I want to keep on composing, writing music, and engaging with the work that makes me feel alive. And also, I also want to outsource the work that has no place in my life other than to conspire to keep me busy, engaged, mediocre, and frankly, tired as hell.
What gets missed in the conversation about AI is exactly how much we seem to want to outsource everything to it, boring tasks as well as fulfilling tasks too. I wouldn't be at all surprised if in ten years most of my life could be handled by AI. This frightens me. I don't want to lose my sense of sovereignty. I don't want to allow someone else, AI or human, the chance to write music for me (unless I'm collaborating, of course, but only with humans, goshdarnit).
It just means more to do the work that makes me feel alive. And, it means more to let go of the busy work that I find incredibly silly.
Balance, baby. Balance.